
Originally Posted by
-stattik-
Ah, I see your dilemma. I had similar issues. (Search for "betty" in the original script and you'll see my workaround.) I've attached a new version of the script that incorporates some of what you did. First, the script will check to see if there's enough crop info from Mencoder's cropdetect to make a good decision and, if not, it will do a little more exhaustive search.
Well, I filed a mencoder bugreport bug 1627 to notify them about my problem with lower bars not being detected. cropdetect does not operate in a way that I was thinking it should, the way it's implemented makes it pretty useless. Too bad.
On the other hand I really like the way you implemented the custom cropping together with comskip - that's great and get's rid of keeping track of series names for letterbox, pillarbox, whatever.

Originally Posted by
-stattik-
... while Mencoder's cropdetect is good at finding the subtle black bars around the picture.
Unfortunately that is not the case when channel logos appear 
Btw., I tried the latest mencoder version from here. It seems to work well and is not so old as the one you are bundling with your package 
Volker
PVR: Phenom 9150e / 4GB / XP / GeForce 8200 / HVR-1600 / GB-PVR 1.4.7